EAB Biological Control Agents Recovered

  • Tetrastichus planipennisi has been recovered at multiple locations in southeastern Minnesota, Twin Cities metro, and Duluth. These finds show that T. planipennisi can survive an extremely cold winter and are establishing and reproducing. These wasps were found by debarking branches and logs and examining them for wasps, dissecting EAB larva and deploying yellow pan traps. 
  • Spathius galinae has been recovered from a site in Duluth, MN. This find shows that S. galinae can overwinter and are establishing and reproducing. These wasps were found by debarking branches and logs and examining them for wasps.
  • Oobius agrili has been recovered from multiple locations in southeastern Minnesota and in the Twin Cities. EAB eggs were collected from bark samples then examined for evidence of parasitism. This detailed presentation showing how to look for Oobius agrili (PDF: 2.89 MB / 52 pages)

Parasitoid Recovery Methods

This method was devised by Dr. Leah Bauer with the USDA Forest Service Northern Research Station in Lansing, MI. A 10 x 50cm section of outer bark is scraped off the trunk of an infested ash tree using a drawknife. The bark is collected by a plastic sheet laid at the base of the tree and then transferred to a paper bag to dry out and avoid the growth of mold while in storage. After the bark has dried for a month, the sample is placed into a sieve and shook for two minutes. Once done sieving the sample, the fine debris is transferred to a ceramic dish and analyzed underneath a dissecting microscope for the presence of parasitized EAB eggs.

Oobius agrili adult under magnification
Collecting bark samples
Bark samples are sieved

Bark samples are sieved

Bark samples are examined to look for EAB eggs

Bark samples are examined to look for EAB eggs

Parasitized EAB egg with the developing Oobius agrili visible inside

 

EAB egg parasitized by Oobius agrili

A method used in conjunction with tree debarking. All intact EAB larvae with no outward signs of parasitism are collected during the process. Larvae are then dissected under a microscope to look for internal immature wasp larvae. The rear end of the insect is removed with a surgical scissors and the innards are pushed out into droplets of water. If the EAB larva is parasitized, the wasp larva(e) will float to the surface.

small insect larvae in pertri dish
T. planipennisi larvae found inside dissected 4th instar EAB larva

 

This method of parasitoid recovery is the most labor intensive and requires the felling of branches or entire trees. Bark is removed in thin layers down to the cambium where EAB larval galleries and intact larvae are documented, collected and examined for evidence of parasitism.

Branches are peeled then examined

Branches are peeled then examined

Immature Tetrastichus planipennisi in an EAB gallery

Immature Tetrastichus planipennisi in an EAB gallery

A method used to collect adult parasitoids by use of pan traps. Yellow bowls are affixed to the trunks of ash trees with shelving brackets and filled with a clear propylene glycol solution. This liquid traps insects that are attracted to the yellow color of the bowl. Traps are sampled weekly throughout the summer. Samples are poured through a filter, frozen and screened for parasitoids in the late fall.

yellow bowl attached to ash tree
Yellow pan trap